Science fantasy writer  
      Alan J. Garner
  • Home
  • The Chosen
  • Terrath
  • Excerpts
  • Other Books
  • Short Stories
  • My Covers
  • New Blog
  • My Cats
  • Guestbook

Dune: Fiction or Fantasy?

4/17/2010

7 Comments

 
Arguably one of the greatest novels ever written, Frank Herbert's Dune is comparable to J.R.R. Tolkien's timeless masterpiece in terms of majesty and scope. Both boast impressive backstories and mesmerising characters. But cannot this classic piece of sci-fi be construed also as a work of fantasy?

Purists on both sides would no doubt strenuously disagree. Dune brims with futuristic technologies typically found in hardcore science fiction: energy shields, lasguns, starships, to name but a few. Lord of the Rings is packed with the fantastical elements of wizardry, plus mystical races  and creatures.

So too does Dune. The sandworms of Arrakis revered by the Fremen - themselves akin to Elves in the broadest sense possible as a people deeply in
tune with the land of their birth - are as overwhelming and enigmatic as dragons. The mysticism fostered by the manipulative Bene Gesserit witches rivals the sorcery enacted by the best and worst spellcasters in fiction. And young Paul Atreides, as the  Kwisatz Haderach, is gifted with prescience, itself echoing the prophecies so often utilized in fantasy writing.

Still unconvinced that Dune can and should be equally regarded as fantasy? Take the Guild Navigators, humans evolved into distinctly new lifeforms through melange saturation. What are these beings, capable of guiding impossibly huge Heighliners across vast stellar distances using limited prescient vision alone, if not magical?

The late, great Arthur C. Clarke summed it up nicely in his Third Law:
Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic.

Dare I suggest that Herbert's epic be reclassified as Science Fantasy. Whatever genre you label it, Dune is a magnificent read and will endure as one of the all time greats of fiction.
7 Comments
Pandora Jewellery link
4/18/2011 05:18:50 pm

We share the opinion on and I really enjoy reading your article.

Reply
NBA jerseys link
4/18/2011 05:22:12 pm

I appreciate your bright ideas in this article. Great work!

Reply
Ádám Oláh
6/2/2012 09:59:29 pm

I would disagree. One of Frank Herbert's ideas was to demonstrate the narrow-mindedness of humanity about themselves, their futures, their opportunities, etc. His principle was to never tell mere fantasy, but to sketch boldly unusual and very hard to follow, yet – in his opinion, which is not to be overseen considering his habit of putting enormous effort in research before writing even a short story or a newspaper article – fully reasonable possibilities. I think it makes the Dune saga much more a large-scale science fiction than merely science fantasy.

If there's true resemblance between the Bene Gesserit and sorcerers or between sandworms and dragons, then it was a rather meant to be a warning: even if things like that seem fantastic, they may appear any time in the future history of mankind. Yes, it's arguable if Herbert had theories to support all the elements of the saga or some (e.g. the Spice) can be considered merely fantastic (even though they're still not impossible to exist), but otherwise, Dune was meant to be a perfectly reasonable alternative to all that computerized-future science fiction.

Reply
kredyty gotowkowe link
7/10/2012 02:22:02 am

It really is really interesting topic you�ve written here . The truth I�m not related to this, but I think is a very good opportunity to learn more about, And as nicely speak about a different subject to which I used to talk with others

Reply
Pozycjonowanie wrocław link
7/11/2012 05:36:24 pm

Rattling superb information can be found on web weblog .

Reply
Serwis laptopów wrocław link
7/17/2012 03:46:41 am

Can I say what a relief to discover 1 who actually knows what theyre preaching about on-line. You definitely recognize how to bring a challenge to light creating it important. More and much more folks genuinely need to take a look at this and recognize why side of your story. I cant believe youre less well-known just because you undoubtedly develop the gift.

Reply
instastalker link
7/17/2020 01:58:41 am

Great job. The way you explain everything is appreciable. Plus the information you share is so to the point. I have been looking for some insight on the

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Novelist Alan J. Garner is author of The Chosen Trilogy and the fantasy series Terrath.

    View my profile on LinkedIn

    Categories

    All
    Paranormal
    SF Science Fiction Or Science Fantasy?
    SF - Science Fiction Or Science Fantasy?

    View my profile on LinkedIn

    Archives

    September 2018
    May 2018
    November 2017
    September 2017
    April 2017
    September 2016
    August 2016
    March 2015
    September 2014
    July 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    February 2014
    November 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    January 2012
    April 2011
    December 2010
    June 2010
    May 2010
    April 2010
    March 2010
    February 2010
    January 2010
    December 2009
    October 2009

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.